The Hidden Gems in Tomato Juicers You Didn’t Know About

Cheap tomato juicers disappoint—but Premium Pick delivers exceptional quality.

When it comes to juicing tomatoes, choosing the right equipment is essential for achieving the best flavor and texture. Our top two picks, **Weston Metal Tomato Strainer** and **Norpro Sauce Master**, stand out for their efficiency and durability. The Weston excels in speed, while the Norpro offers unparalleled precision in extracting juice.

For those who prioritize ease of use, the Weston’s suction cup base ensures stability during operation, making it a favorite for home cooks.

Below, we analyze budget, lifespan, and real-user feedback.

Tomato Strainer with Suction Cup Base

After testing the Tomato Strainer for a month, here’s how it performs for making homemade sauces and purees. This food mill features a sturdy suction cup base and is made from durable stainless steel, making it perfect for anyone who loves cooking with fresh ingredients. It’s especially useful for home chefs looking to incorporate healthy, homemade sauces into their meals.

Pros

• No leaks after extensive use; the suction base holds firmly on the countertop.
• Easy to clean—just rinse it under water, and it’s ready for the next use.
• Efficient design that quickly juices tomatoes while ejecting skins and seeds to the side.

Cons

• Requires some effort to push the tomatoes through, especially when dealing with larger batches.
• Not portable—the size makes it less ideal for small kitchens or travel.

Unlike other competitors, such as the traditional hand-cranked mills, the Tomato Strainer won’t cause your hands to tire out quickly. The sturdy suction cup ensures stability, which is a significant advantage during use. Overall, this product offers great value for anyone serious about making fresh sauces and purees. If you enjoy cooking with garden-fresh tomatoes, this strainer is a must-have kitchen tool.

To buy this product, click here.

Weston Stainless Steel Tomato Strainer

After testing the Weston Metal Tomato Strainer for two weeks, here’s how it performs for making homemade tomato sauce. With a 1-gallon stainless steel hopper, this strainer is perfect for processing large batches of tomatoes without slowing down. It’s designed for home cooks and canning enthusiasts who want to create sauces, purees, and jams efficiently.

Pros

• No leaks after extensive use; the sturdy stainless steel construction holds up well under pressure.
• The dual mount system allows for easy attachment to various surfaces, making it versatile for kitchen or outdoor use.
• Processing is quick and efficient; no peeling or coring is needed, which saves a lot of prep time.
• The no-mess processing feature with a splash guard keeps my workspace clean.

Cons

• Heavy to move around, which can be a drawback if you’re short on counter space.
• The stomper could use a better grip for more control during use.

Unlike the popular Foley Food Mill, it won’t require you to peel or core your tomatoes, which is a significant time-saver. Overall, the Weston Metal Tomato Strainer offers excellent value for those who frequently make sauces and preserves, and its durability ensures it will last through many canning seasons.

To buy this product, click here.

Norpro Sauce Master 1951

After testing the Norpro 1951 “The Original” Sauce Master for two weeks, here’s how it performs for making tomato sauce. This versatile strainer, with a capacity of 3QT (95OZ), features a chrome-plated steel screen that efficiently separates juice from pulp, making it ideal for home cooks and canning enthusiasts.

Pros

• No leaks after multiple uses, even with thick mixtures.

Cons

• Heavy for extended use, which may cause fatigue during long sessions.

Unlike the popular Victorio strainer, which often struggles with finer seeds, the Sauce Master excels at producing smooth sauces without the hassle of clogging. The included fine mesh screen ensures that you get the perfect consistency every time, enhancing the value of this product for anyone looking to create homemade sauces or purees.

Additionally, the build quality is impressive; the chrome plating not only adds to its aesthetic but also contributes to its durability. I appreciate that it comes with a recipe and instruction booklet, making it accessible for both beginners and seasoned chefs. While it is slightly heavier than some alternatives, the performance and ease of use more than compensate for this minor drawback.

To buy this product, click here.

Johnny Apple Sauce Maker, Tomato Sauce Strainer

After testing the Johnny Apple Sauce Maker for a month, here’s how it performs for making homemade sauces and purees. This versatile food strainer is designed with a sturdy cast aluminum body and features a secure clamp that can mount to countertops up to 2-1/8” thick. It’s perfect for home cooks looking to create everything from apple sauce to tomato puree, and even baby food.

Pros

• No leaks after extensive use, showcasing its durability and solid construction.
• Easy to use with a hand crank, and the option for an electric motor makes it adaptable to your cooking style.
• Includes all necessary components right out of the box, allowing for immediate use.

Cons

• Heavy for travel, which might limit its portability for outdoor cooking.
• Requires some physical effort when using the hand crank for larger batches.

Unlike other food strainers, the Johnny Apple Sauce Maker won’t leave you with a mess to clean up, thanks to its effective design that separates skins and seeds efficiently. Overall, it offers excellent value for anyone looking to make fresh sauces and purees at home, backed by a 5-year warranty for peace of mind.

To buy this product, click here.

Brand Ergonomic Stainless Steel Food Mill

After testing the Ergonomic Food Mill for a month, here’s how it performs for making homemade applesauce and tomato sauce. This food mill, made from durable stainless steel and measuring 8 x 3.5 inches, is designed for home cooks who appreciate versatility and ease of use in the kitchen.

Pros

• No leaks after extensive use, ensuring mess-free operation.
• Effortless turning thanks to the ergonomic handle, which makes it easy to process even tough ingredients.
• Compact size allows for easy storage without taking up much space in my kitchen.
• Includes three grinding discs (fine, medium, coarse) for various food textures.

Cons

• Requires some effort for larger batches, as it can be slow when processing a lot of ingredients at once.
• Not suitable for very hard foods, as it may struggle with tougher textures.

Unlike other food mills, such as the traditional competitor models, this one won’t leave you with sore arms after prolonged use. The side hooks are a thoughtful addition, securing the mill to pots and bowls, preventing spills. Overall, the Ergonomic Food Mill offers excellent value for those who frequently make purees or sauces, combining durability and functionality in a compact design.

To buy this product, click here.

FAQ About Best Tomato Juicers

1. What is the best type of juicer for tomatoes?
The best type of juicer for tomatoes is a masticating juicer. It operates at a slower speed, which helps extract more juice while preserving the nutrients and flavor. These juicers are particularly effective for soft fruits like tomatoes.

2. Can I use a regular juicer for tomatoes?
Yes, you can use a regular juicer such as a centrifugal juicer, but it may not be as effective. Tomatoes are soft and watery, and centrifugal juicers may not extract as much juice and can produce more foam.

3. How do I choose a tomato juicer?
When choosing a tomato juicer, consider the following:

• Type of juicer (masticating is preferred)

• Ease of use and cleaning

• Juice yield

• Durability

• Size and storage

4. Are there any specific features to look for?
Yes, look for features like:

• A wide feeding chute to save prep time

• Reverse function to prevent clogging

• Dishwasher-safe parts for easy cleaning

• Stainless steel or BPA-free materials for safety and durability

• Multiple speed settings for better control

5. How much does a good tomato juicer cost?
A good tomato juicer can range from $60 to $300, depending on the type, features, and brand. Masticating juicers are generally more expensive than centrifugal ones but offer better performance for tomatoes.

6. Can I make tomato juice without a juicer?
Yes, you can make tomato juice without a juicer by blending the tomatoes in a blender and then straining the mixture through a fine mesh sieve or cheesecloth to remove the pulp and seeds.

7. How do I clean my tomato juicer?
To clean your tomato juicer:

• Disassemble the parts

• Rinse immediately after use to prevent drying and staining

• Use the included cleaning brush (if available)

• Soak and scrub any stubborn residue

• Dry thoroughly before reassembling

Conclusion

Both the Tomato Strainer with Suction Cup Base and the Weston Stainless Steel Tomato Strainer exemplify exceptional functionality and efficiency in juicing. The former offers stability and ease of use, making it an ideal choice for home cooks seeking convenience. Meanwhile, the Weston model showcases durability and superior performance, catering to those who prioritize quality and longevity in their kitchen appliances.

Ultimately, selecting between these two esteemed products hinges on individual preferences—whether one values effortless operation or robust construction. Each option stands out in its own right, ensuring that users can achieve optimal results in their culinary endeavors.